In the day and age of modern technology, video game press can easily reach all corners of the internet. Unfortunately, some of these talked up games don’t always live up to their circulating rumors. Some titles deliver even more horrific scares than players initially expected, while others can leave much to be desired.
RELATED:10 Best Action Horror Games (According To Metacritic)
While not being objectively bad all around, some of these games just aren’t the bone-chilling experiences the hype made them out to be. Whether they deserved it or not, here are some horror games that had everyone’s attention even before their big release.
10Worth The Hype: Until Dawn
Supermassive Games outdid themselves with the release ofUntil Dawn. It was an incredible interactive horror experience that pulled in both loyal video game fans and newcomers alike. Even if new players weren’t too familiar with video games as a whole, it didn’t stop them from understanding how groundbreaking and terrifying the story ofUntil Dawnwas.
Not only were enemies horrifying, thefear of accidentally offing one of the characterswas constant and lingering.Until Dawndid everything right and definitely was just as scary as rumors made it out to be.
9Over-Hyped: Five Night’s At Freddy’s (Series)
WhenFive Night’s At Freddy’sfirst came out in 2014,YouTubers left and right were putting out as many Let’s Playsas they could. Monitoring Freddy and friends made for a great game, at least at first. The same few jumpscares over and over again can only be effective for so long. On top of that, after pumping out sequel after sequel, theFNaFseries quickly became trite to many players.
After losing track of that one animatronic for the nth time and having Foxy beeline from his keep straight into the player’s face, it loses its spark. Slowly that feeling of dread and fear fades into frustration and boredom instead.FNaFwas frightening but compared to the hype it got during its year of release, some players may feel a bit let down from the feeling of repetition.
8Worth The Hype: Resident Evil 7
After disappointing fans withResident Evil 6back in 2012, Capcom knew it needed to remind its audience whyResident Evilbecame a household name in the first place; and that’s just what the company did with the release ofResident Evil 7in 2017. Being the first mainline game in the series done in first person rather than third,RE7really was the shot in the leg the beloved franchise needed. Capcom went out on a limb and tried something new and different, andit paid off.
RELATED:The 10 Scariest Horror Games On PS4, Ranked
Resident Evil 7received a lot of attention during its release and with its fresh new story, frightening enemies, and eerie environments. Thehype was worth it, as this trip to thedilapidated Baker householdwas less than welcoming.
7Over-Hyped: Ju-On: The Grudge (Haunted House Simulator)
After the theatrical release ofThe Grudgein 2004, almost everyone and their moms were plagued with nightmares of Kayako and her cat son, Toshio. But whenThe Grudgeexpanded into games and came out with a haunted house simulator in 2009, it fell a little flat.
Controls were clunky, the gameplay was slow, and oftentimes, scares were less frightening and almost a little laughable due to the poor graphics. Although the game may not fulfill its main purpose of being scary, it somewhat made a name for itself as anembarrassingly fun to play horror game.
6Worth The Hype: P.T.
AlthoughP.T., unfortunately, didn’t come to fruition in the end, it definitely earned a mention when talking about hyped horror games. The buzz around this simple teaser was astounding, stressing streamers left and right to hurriedly be the first to uncover the secrets hidden within.
This “would have beenSilent Hill” teaser had everyone talking about how baffling it was that a simple hallway could be so terrifying. So much so that even as an incomplete game that isno longer availableon the PlayStation Store,P.T.‘s existenceinspired plenty of indie and AAA developers.
5Over-Hyped: Friday The 13th
After being generouslygifted to PlayStation Plus players for freein October of 2018,Friday The 13thquickly skyrocketed in popularity. Unfortunately, the game itself didn’t quite do all of its spooky reputation justice. Controls felt janky, graphics weren’t the most impressive, and it wasriddled with glitches and bugsthat made the experience more frustrating than scary.
RELATED:10 Times Horror Movie Villains Crossed Over Into Video Games
Overall, there was too much hype behind what essentially felt like an unfinished product. Perhaps Jason should have sat this one out (every single variation of him).
From the momentIsaac Clarkeboarded the Ishimura inDead Spaceand laid eyes on his very first necromorph, players knew the rest of the game was just going to get more and more terrifying. This new take on zombies goes heavy on the body horror, unleashing disgusting mutated monsters on the player around each unsuspecting corner. The game mechanic of strategically dismembering each enemy to ensure they would stay dead cleverly forced players to focus and aim as best they could in the face of fear.
Dead Spaceoverall was a fresh new take on survival horror. It had audiences talking about it, pinned players up against a new gruesome enemy, and somehow made it just as fun as it was harrowing.
3Over-Hyped: Alone In The Dark (2008)
Coming off the success of the series’ long-awaited comeback in 2001 withAlone In The Dark: The New Nightmare, the 2008 installment was quite the drop-off.Alone In The Dark (2008)was notorious for disappointing fans. The game was overambitious and tried to provide the player with too many different experiences, making it feel like a messy amalgamation of too many genres.
The 1992 original game of the same name was revolutionary for the survival horror genre, and this particular installment really seemed to focus on the “survival” rather than the “horror” (unsuccessfully so).
2Worth The Hype: Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Even with its initial release being 10 years ago,Amnesia: The Dark Descenthas easily solidified itself as one of the most iconic horror games to this day. All the hearsay aboutAmnesiabeing an exciting, new, and unnerving experience wasn’t all talk.Amnesiawas also considered a psychological horror game as well as survival, all adding more and more layers to the hair-raising experience.
ThisLovecraftian-inspired gamelived up to all the hype behind its name; whether that fear is from running out of lantern oil or escaping the infamous water monster.
1Over-Hyped: Slender: The Eight Pages
This game was a great “first try” and there’s no doubt it’s a fun time. But wasSlender: The Eight Pagestruly as scary as so many people made it out to be? Sure, it’s exciting running from Slendy while picking up some drawings in a dark forest, but “terrifying” maybe isn’t the right word for this game. Slenderman himself resembles a suit-wearing egg and aside from him, there aren’t really any other threats.
Although a fun game from a small developer,Slender: The Eight Pageswasn’t exactly that chilling of an experience.
NEXT:5 Best Horror-Themed Games That Will Make You Scream For Joy (& 5 That Won’t), According To Metacritic
